Laura Loomer’s Posting Practices are Pissing Me Off
Emerson Pieper, staff writer
There is something that is truly contradictory about claiming to defend the American Dream whilst treating the presence of Muslim Americans in American politics as ‘proof’ that the American Dream is dead. This is the exact contradiction that I see in Laura Loomer’s recent posts, and it is one of the reasons I find her rhetoric so alarming.
Following the midterm elections, Loomer took to X to express her dissatisfaction with the results. In one post, she had declared that America itself was over, claiming that “communists and jihadists are going to open our borders and replace our votes with votes from illegal aliens.” She also criticized representatives for their alleged support of Sharia law and their supposed hatred of America. Rather than acknowledging the election— in which Americans exercised their right to vote— as reality, Loomer is pinning the results as a threat to the country’s existence.
What really stands out to me is how frequently she connects Islam, immigration and political extremism as though they are interchangeable threats. Being Muslim does not make someone a jihadist, and being an immigrant does not make someone a threat to democracy; I fear that is common knowledge. Still, Loomer’s language repeatedly argues against it and encourages suspicion toward entire communities rather than addressing individual political standings.
“I find it incredibly difficult to understand how someone can claim to value American democracy while simultaneously treating the democratic participation of Muslim Americans as a death sentence for the country.”
emerson pieper
Her reaction to Muslim candidates winning the elections spoke volumes to me. Loomer described America as a “failed state” after the announcement that Ilhan Omar was reelected, then posted, “I hope everyone is learning Arabic.” In another post, she responded to the election results by stating again that the country is “cooked,” but “people will get what they deserve.” I find it incredibly difficult to understand how someone can claim to value American democracy while simultaneously treating the democratic participation of Muslim Americans as a death sentence for the country.
In an investigation in August, Al Jazeera documented an anti-Muslim campaign targeting Michigan Senator Abdul El-Sayed, following his primary victory. Loomer was among the people amplifying attacks against him, including calling his candidacy disgusting. Her recent statements have since followed a similar pattern. Rather than focusing on candidates’ policies, their religion became a central reason for her to think it’s okay to argue against their place in American politics.
There is such a striking hypocrisy in her repeated appeals to the patriotism of it all. The United States is built around the idea that citizens have the right to participate in democracy, regardless of their religious beliefs or backgrounds. That belief does not disappear when the people elected are different from those someone personally supports. Democracy cannot simply mean accepting election results when they produce a desirable outcome. Loomer does not seem to understand that, nor does she want to.
I do not agree with Loomer’s characterization of America, nor do I think her repeated generalizations about Muslims and immigrants contribute anything meaningful to political discussion. Criticism of candidates and their policies is perfectly reasonable and everyone does it. Loomer takes a step further and suggests that entire communities represent the downfall of a country, which is something entirely different.
America does not become less American because its representatives speak a different language, practice different religions or come from immigrant backgrounds. If the American Dream is supposed to represent opportunity and freedom, those ideals cannot reasonably be reserved for people who fit one particular image of what an American dream should look like.