Review: “Much Ado About Nothing: A Fantasia” Profoundly Misses the Mark
Kaia Anderson, online publishing coordinator

“Much Ado About Nothing: A Fantasia” is a 90s high school adaptation of Shakespeare’s play “Much Ado About Nothing,” where Claudio and Hero, and Benedick and Beatrice attempt to fall in love despite high school drama and rumors causing conflict and mayhem. Alex Barreto Hathaway, the director of the show, describes it as 90s rom-com, college sports, and Shakespeare. The show runs from Nov. 12-14 and 19-22. I had the opportunity to see the show on Nov. 11, their final rehearsal before opening night.
The show began with the introduction of our cast and setting up the romantic tensions between our couples. Claudio sets his sights on Hero, while Beatrice and Benedick start their war of wit. Enunciation was certainly a problem, especially at the beginning. There were several moments throughout the whole show where I had no clue what the actors were saying. However, as the play continued, it certainly became less of an issue.
Graedyn Wendt, who portrayed Benedick, was an absolute delight to watch. They completely embodied Benedick. It was easy to understand what their intentions were, and they not only charmed Beatrice but the audience as well. Their chemistry with Nox GebbenGreen sold their will-they, won’t-they dynamic. GebbenGreen didn’t fail to shine in scenes separate from Wendt either. GebbenGreen got more than a few laughs at their outrageous and confident physicality.
Prakash Landis and MJ Kinsey portrayed the other romantic pair, Claudio and Hero. Landis’ Claudio is a romantic who falls quickly for Hero. Kinsey’s Hero, however, is quick to kick him to the curb when the relationship goes south. She “don’t want no scrub” after all. Throughout the misunderstanding and heartbreak, you cannot help but root for the young lovers to finally be happy, which is definitely in no small part due to Landis’ and Kinsey’s acting and chemistry.

Klaus Solko, who also went to the viewing, had this to say, “I’m not really a fan of Shakespeare adaptations and I wasn’t necessarily looking forward to this show, but the energy that the actors brought turned me around. The physical comedy that Graedyn and Nox brought was hilarious, I don’t think I have ever laughed that much during a show. I’m still not 100% convinced about all the choices or the adaptation itself but the clear commitment and work that everyone put in shines on stage. The actors really made the show.”
For this modern adaptation, music and dance were heavily used. During scene transitions, live instrumentals were played by SuperNegative, who were also featured in the show as the Watch – a group in charge of patrolling the halls and who help uncover the villain’s plot. There were also live vocals, where the characters like Wendt, Drew Bechay as Coach, and Kyle Chang as Balthasar would sing during the scene. This is when diction once again became a problem, with raps becoming unintelligible. Simple choreography was also poorly executed, with a few actors struggling to keep up with the steps.
According to cast members, that night was their first full run-through. This lack of preparation unfortunately showed through with actors forgetting, not being fully confident, and one seemingly reading their lines off a clipboard. Ad-libs also proved to be distracting, with characters switching from Shakespearean to modern English. During notes, Barreto Hathaway even noted that actors were still learning cues.
“It just really took me out of scenes to go from following heavy metaphors and killer quips to hearing characters in the background chanting ‘pizza’ or throwing around slang. Though I can understand that this was a huge part of the setting being a 90s high school. At times I just found it to be confusing the scene.” Solko added.

Pacing also proved to be a problem; there were several moments in many scenes where there was simply nothing happening. Even though the director’s cut attempted to streamline the story, it instead left characters lacking motivation and left audience members confused about what was happening. Act one lasted approximately an hour, and act two was about 40 minutes.
“I would still recommend going out to see and support the show and its wonderful cast. Despite its issues, Wendt and GebbenGreen will definitely have you leaving the theater with a smile on your face.”
kaia anderson
I would still recommend going out to see and support the show and its wonderful cast. Despite its issues, Wendt and GebbenGreen will definitely have you leaving the theater with a smile on your face.