The Blue Wave, Identity Politics and Nihilism
Teyah Parent, features editor
It’s incredibly frustrating watching people on the internet claim that the current political progress is meaningless just because it isn’t their ideal version of political revolution. Every time something good happens, there is an impulse among corners of the left to explain why it is insufficient. At what point does political consciousness become so consumed by ideological purity that it loses the ability to recognize actual, tangible improvement in people’s lives?
“Where does the belief that voting for Democrats is pointless come from? When did participating in a broken system make you complicit in everything wrong with it? What is the alternative? Where is the revolution?”
Teyah parent
Where does the belief that voting for Democrats is pointless come from? When did participating in a broken system make you complicit in everything wrong with it? What is the alternative? Where is the revolution?
If your entire political philosophy consists of telling others that voting is insufficient while contributing absolutely nothing to the alternative, then I genuinely can’t care about your political philosophy. You cannot insist that people should abandon the existing political system without offering a viable alternative pathway. You cannot dismantle a political system when you cannot engage with the immediate political realities of that system. How are we supposed to believe that refusing to participate in the available political process is somehow a meaningful step toward replacing it, despite having no organized alternative taking its place? That is posturing.
This is why I find so much post-2024 political discourse infuriating. There were people who refused to vote for Harris because they disagreed with a few of her positions. Those concerns were not unreasonable, but there is a difference between criticizing a candidate and refusing to acknowledge the consequences of your political decisions. Refusing to vote or casting a protest vote for a third-party candidate with no electoral pathway did not bring the country closer to a progressive political future.
Now, we get a win during the midterm and people are rushing to explain why we should not be celebrating. Texas is blue. That is something worth celebrating, along with so many firsts. But congratulations, you have identified that an election did not single-handedly resolve every structural problem in the country. Would you like a fucking medal?
The same frustration applies to the bizarre insistence that we should stop acknowledging the identities of elected officials. Whenever someone celebrates the election of a queer person, a Black politician, or an Indigenous representative, somebody appears to ask why we cannot just refer to them by their name. Why does their identity have to matter? Why can’t we just treat everyone equally?
Because we fucking don’t. We do not live in that world. We live in a country where people’s identities are actively weaponized against them. We have politicians running campaigns built around demonizing transgender people, immigrants, racial minorities and religious communities. We have advertisements explicitly designed to make voters afraid of people based on their gender or the color of their skin. The election of these representatives is meaningful precisely because minorities have historically been excluded, marginalized and discouraged from participating in public life. These achievements deserve recognition because the circumstances that made them exceptional deserve scrutiny.
I am not going to let somebody on the internet convince me that a political victory is worthless. I am much more interested in actually getting somewhere than I am in winning an ideological pissing contest with people who seem to think being perpetually disappointed is a political accomplishment.